Doctor Answers: Effectiveness of Flomax for Kidney Stones 

In recent medical advancements, Flomax (tamsulosin) has emerged as a potential treatment for kidney stones, repurposed from its original use in benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH). But how effective is Flomax in treating kidney stones? Can it replace surgical procedures and other therapeutic options for this condition?

While small kidney stones may pass unnoticed, larger ones result in severe pain and distressing symptoms that lead individuals to seek immediate medical attention. Symptoms of kidney stones include flank pain, blood in urine, nausea, vomiting, and a burning sensation while urinating. The pain, often intense, can radiate to various parts of the body, sometimes accompanied by sweating and may signal the stone’s movement through the urinary tract.

It is estimated that most people will experience symptoms of kidney stones at some stage in their lives. They form from calcium oxalate crystals or uric acid crystals. Not all cases of kidney stones exhibit all symptoms, but the presence of blood in urine is a crucial indication of stone passage or potential urinary tract injury.

For individuals considering Flomax for kidney stones, understanding how Flomax works in cases of kidney stones, its effectiveness, side effects, and its role in replacing traditional therapies is crucial.

To provide a thorough understanding of Flomax’s role in treating kidney stones, we consulted with Dr. Parra, a renowned urologist specializing in kidney health. During our discussion, Dr. Parra shared his expert insights on the mechanisms, effectiveness, recommended dosages, and alternative treatments for kidney stones. Dr. Parra has contributed extensive research and resources to this article, ensuring that all information is accurate and comprehensive. Throughout the content, you’ll find links to these materials, allowing you to explore each topic in greater depth.

Additionally, all content has been thoroughly reviewed by a medical professional to ensure its accuracy and reliability.

Q: Can you explain how Flomax works in treating kidney stones?

Dr. Parra answers: Flomax is an alpha-blocker, and there are various forms of alpha-adrenergic receptors in the urinary tract. These receptors are linked to smooth muscle. When activated, they trigger muscle contraction. Flomax works by occupying these alpha-adrenergic receptors, effectively blocking adrenaline from binding. Unlike adrenaline, tamsulosin does not activate the receptors but rather takes up space, preventing other molecules from interacting with them. This relaxation of smooth muscle isn’t limited to the prostatic urethra. Still, it extends to the rest of the urinary tract, particularly the distal portion of the ureters and the bladder neck, where alpha-1D receptors are more concentrated.

When kidney stones move through the ureters, the smooth muscle typically contracts, which can trap the stone and limit its progression. In these cases, Flomax mediates the relaxation of smooth muscles in the ureters, improving urine flow and resolving obstructions caused by kidney stones. This action also reduces the risk of mechanical obstructions in the urinary tract, such as hydronephrosis (swelling of the kidney due to urine accumulation) and complete urinary obstruction, which is an emergency requiring immediate medical attention.

Q: What is the recommended dosage of Flomax for treating kidney stones?

Dr. Parra answers: The standard dosage of Flomax for kidney stones is 0.4 mg, taken orally once a day. Patients should continue this dosage until the passage of the stone. It is important to follow your doctor’s instructions regarding dosage and duration to maximize effectiveness and minimize potential side effects.

Q: How effective is Flomax in treating kidney stones?

Dr. Parra answers: Flomax (tamsulosin) has shown efficacy in various studies related to kidney stone treatment. It can significantly reduce the time it takes for stones to pass through the urinary tract. For instance, one study reported a 72% stone expulsion rate in patients using Flomax compared to only 30% in those receiving placebo medications. Additionally, Flomax has proven effective in eliminating kidney stones smaller than 10 millimeters.

Q: How does Flomax specifically help in the passage of kidney stones?

Dr. Parra answers: Flomax facilitates kidney stones’ passage by relaxing the ureters’ smooth muscles. This relaxation widens the urethra, allowing stones to pass more easily and reducing the likelihood of them becoming trapped. By improving urine flow, Flomax helps alleviate the obstruction caused by kidney stones, thereby reducing pain and the need for more invasive treatments.

Q: Can you elaborate on how Tamsulosin affects the passage time of kidney stones?

Dr. Parra answers: Studies have demonstrated that Tamsulosin can significantly reduce the elimination time for kidney stones. For example, one clinical trial found that patients taking Tamsulosin expelled their stones in an average of 7 days, compared to 9 days for those on placebo. 

In a subgroup of patients with stones smaller than 10 millimeters located in the distal ureters, Tamsulosin promoted stone expulsion in just 4 days, compared to 7 days with traditional medications. While Flomax is most effective for stones in the distal ureters, it also provides a notable reduction in elimination time for stones in proximal areas of the urinary tract.

Q: What does current research indicate about Flomax’s effectiveness in treating kidney stones?

Dr. Parra answers: Various clinical trials have evaluated the use of Flomax in treating kidney stones, particularly ureteral calculi in the distal ureters where alpha-adrenergic receptors are more concentrated. 

These studies have shown that patients receiving Tamsulosin in the emergency room required less pain medication and fewer anesthetics. Additionally, there was a significant reduction in hospital stay durations and a lower need for surgical removal of stones. Implementing Flomax in kidney stone treatment could potentially lead to a 29% reduction in emergency department visits and a 24% decrease in healthcare expenses.

Q: Are alpha-blockers like Flomax recommended for kidney stones under 10mm?

Dr. Parra answers: According to the 2016 American Urological Association guidelines, alpha-blockers may be beneficial for treating stones smaller than 10 millimeters. However, research remains inconclusive regarding the use of Tamsulosin for kidney stones. A study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association concluded that Tamsulosin was not effective in increasing the passage rate for stones smaller than 9mm compared to placebo. Therefore, while Flomax can be useful for larger stones, its effectiveness for smaller stones is still under debate.

Q: Besides Flomax, what other treatment options are available for kidney stones?

Dr. Parra answers: There are numerous therapeutic strategies for managing kidney stones, both pharmacological and surgical. The choice of treatment depends on the size and location of the stones. Here are some alternative options:

Thiazide Diuretics

Thiazide diuretics are commonly prescribed to encourage urinary flow and reduce urinary calcium levels, which may help prevent the recurrence of kidney stones in susceptible individuals.

Potassium Citrate

Potassium citrate is recommended for patients who form calcium stones. It helps reduce the risk of stone recurrence by increasing urinary pH and decreasing the formation of uric acid stones. Additionally, potassium supplementation may be necessary when thiazide diuretics are used.

Allopurinol

Allopurinol is used to reduce the production and accumulation of uric acid. It is typically prescribed for patients with kidney stones who have normal urinary calcium levels but high uric acid levels in the urine.

Dietary Modifications

Dietary changes are often recommended to prevent kidney stones. These include increasing fluid intake to maintain adequate hydration, reducing sodium consumption, limiting non-dairy animal protein, and aiming for 1,000 to 1,200 mg of dietary calcium per day. Additionally, reducing the intake of oxalate-rich foods is more important than decreasing calcium consumption.

Surgical Measures

Various minimally invasive and invasive procedures are available to clear kidney stones, depending on their size and location. These include extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy, ureteroscopy, and percutaneous nephrolithotomy. Some procedures may require a postoperative ureteral stent, while others are performed on an outpatient basis.

Top Concerns About Flomax’s Effectiveness for Kidney Stones

Q: Can Flomax help pass kidney stones larger than 10mm, or is it only for smaller stones?

Dr. Parra answers: In most studies, Flomax (tamsulosin) is recommended for stones larger than 5mm but smaller than 10mm. This is because a 1cm kidney stone has a very low chance of passing spontaneously or with conservative treatment. Treatment protocols and review articles recommend surgical treatment after 1cm, especially if the stone is lodged in the proximal ureter.

Keep in mind that a low chance of passing doesn’t mean it’s impossible. However, you are more likely to experience painful symptoms. A recent study of tamsulosin in patients with 10-15mm kidney stones confirms that only 15% of patients passed the stones spontaneously, and their adverse effects were higher than the placebo group.

Treatment protocols are designed considering a high chance of treatment success. That’s why it’s not recommended to try Flomax alone as a treatment for kidney stones larger than 10mm. In some cases, it can be considered an option after extracorporeal shockwave lithotripsy. However, this type of management should be guided by your doctor and not taken as a decision on your own as a patient.

It is important to remember that passing kidney stones is an off-label use of Flomax (tamsulosin). It has not been approved by the FDA, leading to some controversy. However, studies show it can be highly effective and may contribute to successful conservative treatment. The success rate is better with stones larger than 6mm because smaller stones are more likely to pass, even without tamsulosin. In other words, if you have stones smaller than 6mm, they may pass spontaneously, even if you don’t use Flomax.

Q: Why might Flomax not be effective for some people with kidney stones?

Dr. Parra answers:  Some people may not find Flomax (tamsulosin) effective in removing kidney stones because sometimes it is not what they need to pass them. Kidney stones may have an unsuitable shape to pass with conservative treatment. They can be lodged in unfavorable urinary tract areas that do not respond to tamsulosin treatment. There is also a pain threshold that’s individual for each patient and dictates whether or not they experience symptoms.

Such differences make conservative treatment more complex and difficult to predict. Flomax is a conservative treatment that relies on a mechanical change in the contractile aspects of the urinary tract. By relaxing the ureters and urethra, tamsulosin helps the urinary flow drag the kidney stones to let them pass. However, some areas, such as the proximal ureter, are more difficult to reach, according to studies, even after using Flomax (tamsulosin), and may require surgical treatment.

As opposed to conservative treatment, surgery is a clear-cut way to access the origin of the problem and take it away. Patients won’t respond the same way to tamsulosin since our kidney stone issues are mostly mechanical and not chemical. However, it is still an excellent way to help patients avoid surgical treatment, even if it’s still considered an off-label use.

Q: Could Flomax make the passage of kidney stones more painful in any way?

Dr. Parra answers: Quite the opposite. Studies on Flomax (tamsulosin) for kidney stones have shown once and again that using this drug can reduce pain symptoms in these patients. Kidney stone clearance time was reduced from 12 to 8 days, and patients had less need for analgesic drugs.

Kidney stones hurt because they scratch and irritate the ureters and the urethra as they pass. The nerve terminals in this area reach the spine and are translated in the brain as referred pain in the pelvic area that sometimes radiates into the middle portion of the thigh. It happens because the kidney stones are larger than the urinary tract they should go through.

The ureters and urethra have varying diameters, ranging from 6 to 8 mm. Very small stones are not likely to cause pain unless they have an irregular shape with spikes or salients. Stones larger than 5 mm may cause symptoms, especially when the urethra is tight. Flomax relaxes the muscles around the urethra to increase the diameter of the urinary tract and facilitate kidney stone clearance. Doing so reduces the chance of scratching and irritation in the urinary tract, and pain terminals are not stimulated.

Since Flomax (tamsulosin) does not increase the pain threshold or change our brain chemistry in response to pain, there is no reason why it should increase pain sensation. However, some patients may report pain after starting treatment with tamsulosin precisely because the urinary tract is widening and allowing lodged kidney stones to pass. Such symptoms, if present, are likely relieved with over-the-counter painkillers.

Q: Can Flomax help prevent new kidney stones from forming, or does it only assist with passing existing stones?

Dr. Parra answers: Studies show that Flomax (tamsulosin) can be used to treat kidney stones and as a prevention strategy to reduce the risk of recurrence. It’s not because tamsulosin prevents kidney stone formation but because it aids the urinary tract in eliminating crystals that accumulate into kidney stones before they assemble. Tamsulosin can also contribute to asymptomatic clearance when kidney stones are present but still very small.

Thus, patients may describe reduced kidney stone problems after using Flomax. This effect is not associated with a reduced rate of kidney stone formation. It is rather due to an enhanced elimination of calcium, oxalate, uric acid, or phosphate crystals before they stick together and form a large kidney stone.

Remember, kidney stone formation is more of a chemical than a mechanical process. However, it is associated with mechanical aspects, such as hydration and urinary tract diameter. Good hydration provides adequate urine flow to eliminate crystal-forming substances in the urine before they concentrate and crystalize. An increased urinary tract diameter allows small, asymptomatic crystals to pass unnoticed. Flomax (tamsulosin) aids in the latter, relaxing the musculature around the urinary tract and increasing its diameter.

Conclusion

Flomax has become an essential part of the treatment regimen for kidney stones, particularly for stones larger than 10mm and those located in the distal ureters. Its ability to relax smooth muscles in the urinary tract can significantly reduce the passage time of stones and alleviate symptoms. However, despite its effectiveness, Flomax can have severe side effects and may interact with various medications, including warfarin and vasodilators. Therefore, it is crucial to consult with your doctor about your current medications before starting Flomax.

Flomax effectively induces relaxation of smooth muscles in the urinary tract, reducing the risk of stone entrapment and urinary obstruction. While guidelines suggest that alpha-blockers like Flomax benefit stones under 10mm, some research indicates limited effectiveness for smaller stones. In such cases, dietary modifications and sodium reduction may be more appropriate to facilitate stone passage.

Before taking Flomax, discuss both the benefits and drawbacks of this medication with your doctor. Flomax can be an effective treatment option depending on the size and location of your kidney stones. For smaller stones, lifestyle changes and dietary adjustments may help speed up the passing process without needing medication.

If you are considering Flomax for kidney stones, ensure you thoroughly discuss with your healthcare provider to determine the best approach based on your specific condition and medical history.

Our Medical Review Process

At Ben’s Natural Health, we are committed to transparency, clear communication, and scientific accuracy. All of our content is carefully crafted by medical professionals and undergoes thorough reviews every 12 to 24 months. This ensures that the information remains up-to-date, reliable, and supported by credible research. We only reference peer-reviewed studies from respected medical journals, providing full citations and direct links to verify the accuracy of the content. To learn more about our detailed review process and research standards, visit our medical review process.

Our Editorial Guidelines

For over 25 years, Ben’s Natural Health has been a trusted source for scientifically accurate information on natural health topics. Our rigorous editorial guidelines ensure that all content is reliable and trustworthy. Articles are written by accredited experts, including doctors, dietitians, nutritionists, fitness trainers, and surgeons, and are independently reviewed for quality. We value transparency and include the qualifications and full biographies of our contributors at the start of each article. To learn more about our approach to writing and fact-checking, please read our editorial guidelines.

Medical Disclaimer

The information on this blog is intended for educational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. While the content is reviewed by licensed doctors, it is not customized to your individual health needs. Always consult with your primary care physician or another qualified healthcare provider before making any health decisions. Do not disregard professional medical advice or delay seeking it based on information you read here. Use of this blog’s content is at your own risk.